NewsLong-known celestial body behaves strangely - is the asteroid...

Long-known celestial body behaves strangely – is the asteroid a comet?

A celestial body that has been known for a long time suddenly does something unexpected – that raises questions: Is (248370) 2005 QN173 not an asteroid at all, but a comet?

Tucson / Frankfurt – Asteroids and comets are actually two completely different classes of celestial bodies, which primarily have one thing in common: Both are leftovers from the time when the solar system was formed. Apart from that, comets are designed like “dirty snowballs”, they consist of dust and loose rock that is held together by ice. When a comet gets closer to the sun, part of the ice sublimes and becomes directly gaseous – the tail characteristic of comets is created. Asteroids, on the other hand, are usually boulders that orbit the sun without developing a tail.

Actually, asteroids and comets are completely different types of celestial bodies in astronomy. Occasionally, however, researchers discover an object that does not seem to fit into either of the two categories – or into both. The latter applies to the celestial body with the cryptic designation (248370) 2005 QN173. The celestial body, which was discovered back in 2005, has long been mistaken for an asteroid. It is located in the asteroid belt (also called the main belt) between Mars and Jupiter and was inconspicuous for a long time. But now researchers at the Planetary Science Institute (PSI) in Tucson (Arizona) have announced that the asteroid is active, that is, it is outgassing and has developed a tail. The corresponding study was accepted for publication by the specialist journal Astrophysical Journal Letters.

Das Objekt (248370) 2005 QN173 ist links oben zu sehen (lange Spur). Es befindet sich im Hauptgürtel, in dem sich eigentlich Asteroiden aufhalten, scheint aber eher ein Komet zu sein.


The object (248370) 2005 QN173 can be seen at the top left (long track). It is located in the main belt, where asteroids are actually located, but it seems to be more of a comet.

Comet or asteroid? Celestial Body (248370) 2005 QN173 seems to be both

“Its behavior strongly suggests that its activity can be traced back to the sublimation of icy material,” explains the lead author of the study, Henry Hsieh from PSI. This makes the asteroid a so-called “main belt comet”, explained Hsieh when presenting his study at a virtual meeting of the American Astronomical Society. “It is one of only about 20 objects that are currently confirmed or suspected main belt comets,” said Hsieh. Some of the 20 objects were also observed to be active only once, while activity had already been observed several times for the celestial body (248370) 2005 QN137.

“247370 can be viewed as an asteroid and a comet, or more precisely as a main belt asteroid, which was only recently recognized to be a comet,” Hsieh tries to define the celestial body. “It meets the physical definitions of a comet because it is very likely icy and blows dust into space, even if it has the orbit of an asteroid,” continues Hsieh. “This duality and the blurring of the lines between what were previously thought to be two completely different types of objects – asteroids and comets – is an essential part of what makes these objects so interesting,” says Hsieh happily.

Main belt comet and asteroid in one: (248370) 2005 QN173 is exciting for research

Hsieh’s research team found that the comet’s core, which is surrounded by a cloud of dust, is 3.2 kilometers in diameter. In July 2021, the comet’s tail was longer than 720,000 kilometers and around 1,400 kilometers wide. The very narrow tail shows that the dust particles are moving away from the core at very low speeds and that the comet’s gas flow is very weak. This in turn suggests that something else is helping the dust to escape from the comet’s nucleus – the nucleus may be rotating quickly and thus hurling the dust out into space. However, more observations are needed to confirm this, says Hsieh.

All important news from astronomy and space travel straight to your inbox

PSI researcher Hsieh and his colleague David Jewitt were the first to discover the new class of main belt comets in 2006. The rare comets in the main belt are particularly exciting for research: there is the theory that asteroid impacts once brought a large part of the water to earth. Since outgassing comets in the main belt are likely to mean that they still contain water, they could be worthwhile targets for future exploration. (tab)

South Korea suffers another severe defeat: space mission "unfinished"

It just won't work. Another space mission from South Korea fails. But President Moon Jae-in already has new plans.

NASA: Rover recordings show what the “sound of Mars” sounds like

Research knows a lot about Mars, but what does the red planet actually sound like? The Nasa rover "Perseverance" and two commercially available microphones show it.

SpaceX and Nasa: Astronaut Matthias Maurer's flight is postponed

The German astronaut Matthias Maurer has to wait a little longer for his first space flight: his start date for the ISS has been postponed again.

Meteorite hits next to sleeping woman

A meteorite terrors a woman in Canada while she was sleeping. When she wakes up, she sees a hole in the ceiling and a stone on her pillow.

Peter Schilling delivers the soundtrack for the flight to the ISS

“Completely detached from the earth”: Peter Schilling's mega-success “Major Tom” is probably the space anthem of all. Now the singer has accompanied another astronaut on his journey.